Tuesday, July 10, 2012


COMPARING EU AND INDIA (Disparity & Competitiveness)  

Recent World Economic Forum (weform.org) analysis (four Europes) prompted comparison between continental Europe (EU) and sub-continent India. We would begin with historical background and try to ponder into current scenario. At the onset, this comparison may seem absurd like comparing ‘apples with bananas’. However, when we probe deep into the matter, similarities, challenges and prospective future becomes evident.

Historically, after Second World War when allies (UK, France, USA and Russia) redefined new boundaries in Europe (EU), continent was in shambles. Marshall Plan from new super power gave new dose of life. Similarly, Indian subcontinent was not blessed with any donor and so by following ‘Soviet model of five-year plan’, India struggled with aid and borrowed money.  

New EU emerged with victorious powers (UK and France) and banished powers (Germany and Italy) surrounded by peripheral states like Spain, Greece, Scandinavian and ex-communist economies. In Indian context, because it gained independence from single power (UK), it remained relatively coherent with same level of poverty and development. India had strong regional, linguistic and cultural diversity to tackle. Conversely, EU had to cater to individual nationalistic and historical identities of each state / country.

According to WEF, four broad groups of European countries with distinctive competitive performances seem to emerge in EU. These four “Europes” are :
* Nordic Europe, composed of Sweden, Finland and Denmark (Norway can be added)
* Western Europe composed of the Netherlands, Austria, Germany (ex-WWII-power), United Kingdom (ex-WWII-power), Luxembourg, Belgium, France (ex-WWII-power), Estonia and Ireland
* Southern and Eastern Europe, composed of Slovenia, Portugal, Spain, the Czech Republic, Cyprus, Malta, Latvia, Lithuania, Italy (ex-WWII-power), Slovak Republic, Poland and Hungary
* Southeast Europe, composed of Greece, Romania and Bulgaria

Similarly, in India, different states can be identifies according to progress and infrastructure / standard-of-life.
* Southern states – Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, Andhra Pradesh and Kerala (equivalent to Nordic Europe with high level of education and technologically advanced)
* Western States – Maharasthra, Gujarat, Goa (economically / commercial advanced)
* Central & Northern States – Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh, Haryana / Punjab / Himachal Pradesh, Uttranchal and Jammu & Kashmir (Politically important)
* Eastern States – West Bengal, Bihar, Orissa, Assam, Meghalaya, Nagaland, Manipur, Tripura, Sikkim, and Arunachal Pradesh (Relatively less developed)  

EU has been struggling to have administrative and financial reforms to have a federal structure incorporating ‘different Europe with diversified aspiration’. Only future would tell whether currency unification (EURO) or welfare-benefits would be uniform or descend into political chaos. India has been able to distribute funds from ‘Federal source’ to have manageable disparity among her states.

No comments:

Post a Comment